Stainless steel brake lines upgrade: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
 
(42 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Category:Brakes]]
[[Category:Brakes]]
__TOC__
==Why stainless lines?==
With all the changes you can make to an EX250 that are cosmetic, sometimes it's nice to do something that actually makes the bike work better. A great and relatively inexpensive, yet highly effective, change in your Ninjette enjoyment can be achieved by replacing the stock front brake line with an aftermarket replacement stainless steel brake line. What will this gain you?  
With all the changes you can make to an EX250 that are cosmetic, sometimes it's nice to do something that actually makes the bike work better. A great and relatively inexpensive, yet highly effective, change in your Ninjette enjoyment can be achieved by replacing the stock front brake line with an aftermarket replacement stainless steel brake line. What will this gain you?  


:1) Better lever feel (especially on older bikes)
*Better lever feel  
:2) Less perceived brake fade in repetitive braking  
*Less brake fade in repetitive braking  
:3) New brake fluid! (It's about time anyway, isn't it?)
*Greatly decreased stopping distance 
:4) New brake pads (Well, while you're there...)
*New brake fluid (about time anyway, isn't it?)
*New brake pads (while you're there...)
"Just the front?!?" you ask? Yes, although if you like matching sparkly bits, go whole hog and do the rear as well. Any tricked-out larger street bike has 'em, why shouldn't you?  Most line manufacturers these days also have colored line covers to match your bike's color. Most of your braking power comes from the front anyway.... And, think about how the extra stopping power out back will affect your riding. Most people don't need or want it on a 250.
 
Here's why SS is better: The rubber lines expand with pressure. The SS lines don't (at least nowhere near as much). When you squeeze the brake lever on a stock line, some of that energy goes into expanding the rubber, instead of squeezing the brake pads together. With the SS line, that energy is no longer wasted. The end result is a brake that feels crisper and more definite. It makes the system feel much more precise and high-quality, with a greater sense of control.
 
"Just the front?" you ask? Opinions are somewhat divided:
 
*[https://www.ninja250.org/Jim%20Race Jim Race]: Yes, since the majority of your braking power comes from the front anyway.... Although, if you like matching sparkly bits, go whole hog and do the rear as well. Most of the manufacturers these days have colored covers to match your bike's color. Think first about how the extra stopping power out back will affect your riding.  
 
*[https://www.ninja250.org/Wes Wes]: When you have rear SS lines, you have a direct connection between your foot and the brake pads. It's like a rod. When you have rubber lines, they flex outward as you apply pressure, on a slight time delay. So, it's like a rod on a spring. The older the rubber lines, the springier they are. SS lines give you ''control''.
 
*[https://www.ninja250.org/IanJ IanJ]: I installed SS lines both front and rear on my first bike, and liked it, but didn't really notice much difference in rear feel.  It was better, but not a lot better.  On my second bike, I opted to skip the SS rear line and haven't regretted it.
 
*[https://www.ninja250.org/agradzki agradzki]: I have HH sintered pads on the rear and I haven't even locked up the rear yet (despite epic braking power) because you can feel the wheel speed in your hand and foot so easily. With the rubber lines there would be ''no'' feedback until you started fishtailing.
 
*[https://www.ninja250.org/BrianM BrianM]: In the past when I used SS rear lines, I had to bleed air ''into'' the system to get the rear ''less'' touchy. Before doing that, I'd encounter situations where I'd lock the tire. Since I use the rear brake quite a bit, having the rear wheel lock up with very little foot movement was a headache and resulted in less smoothness, not more.


A generally ignored part of the service schedule is that OEM brake lines should be replaced every four years. So, if your bike is more than three years old, this may be part of your scheduled maintenance. The price is nearly the same, and with stainless you get a much better product. Board recommendation for life expectancy on stainless is five years.  
==Brake lines need to be replaced anyway...==


All the major manufacturers ([http://www.galferusa.com/MOTO.html Galfer], [http://www.spieglerusa.com/cfm/brakelines.cfm Spiegler], [http://www.goodridge.net/usa/motorcycle.htm Goodridge]) are equally good. You can also get ss lines made up from a reputable local hot rod/speed shop. Contact your local dealer, or use a search engine to find out who sells them online. There are other makers out there, too, so poke around. eBay has dealers who carry parts as well.
A generally ignored part of the service schedule is that OEM brake lines should be replaced every four years. So, if your bike is more than three years old, this should be part of your scheduled maintenance. Recommendation for life expectancy on stainless lines is five years.  


[http://cyclebrakes.com/ Cycle Brakes] is a good place to start. They have a lot of info on their site, different colors to choose from, and they carry all sorts of brake-related stuff.  
[http://cyclebrakes.com/ Cycle Brakes] is a good place to start. They have a lot of info on their site, different colors to choose from, and they carry all sorts of brake-related stuff.  


All three of the top brands sell through dealers. These may be brick & mortar or online. Currently (July, 2007), only Galfer has a kit for the EX250; with Goodridge you'll have to use a universal line. This is generally not recommended for a novice. Spiegler would like to have a kit, and are looking for someone to send in their old lines and fittings so they can make one up.  
All three of the top brands ([http://www.galferusa.com/ Galfer], [http://www.spieglerusa.com/cfm/brakelines.cfm Spiegler], [http://www.goodridge.net/usa/motorcycle.htm Goodridge]) are, for most bikes, equally good. However, last time we checked only Galfer had a kit for the EX250. With Goodridge you'd have to use a universal line. This is generally not recommended. Spiegler claims to have a kit, but theirs is far from plug-and-play. It involves bending some of the fittings, and we don't like it because of that. Safety-related items should work right out of the box.
 
As of 2012, [http://www.venhill.co.uk/ Venhill], a British company, has started selling Ninja 250 kits for the F and J series. We've only had a couple people use them, but they like them and have good things to say about their US distributor's customer service. See them at [http://www.venhillusa.com Venhill Website].
 
'''Galfer part numbers'''
 
On [http://www.galferusa.com/ Galfer site] pdf:
 
*front: FK003D249 
*rear: FK003D249R
 
At [http://www.cyclebrakes.net/index.asp?PageAction=PRODSEARCH&txtSearch=+D249&btnSearch=GO&Page=1 Cycle Brakes]:
 
*front: FK003D249-1 
*rear: FK003D249-R 
*Front & rear kit:  COMBOD249-1F-1R
 
'''[http://www.venhillusa.com Venhill Website] - [http://stores.ebay.com/venhilldirect Venhill Ebay Store] part numbers'''
 
*front: KAW-2006FC
*rear: KAW-2006RC
*front & rear kit: KAW-2006FRC
 
Venhill photos
 
[[image:venhill 1.jpg|130px]]
[[image:venhill 2-2.jpg|75px]]
 


If color is important to you, take a look at the [http://www.spieglerusa.com/images/AllFittings-large.jpg Spiegler fittings page], as soon as Spiegler starts carrying a kit for the 250, that is.  
The manufacturers generally sell through dealers (except Venhill). Contact your local dealer, or use a search engine to find out who sells them online. eBay has dealers who carry Galfer parts. You can also get ss lines made up from a reputable local hot rod or speed shop.  


One thing to make sure and look for is that the line has a plastic covering over the steel braid. Without this, you run the risk of lines cutting through fenders, radiators, or even tires. This is generally not a problem. You'll probably be trying to decide what color your covering will be; just make sure that the line comes with one before you order.
One thing to make sure and look for is that the line has a plastic covering over the steel braid. Without this, you run the risk of lines cutting through fenders, radiators, or even tires. Most suppliers have this taken care of; in fact, you'll probably be trying to decide what color your covering will be. Just make sure that the line comes with one before you order.


Price is usually pretty cheap, somewhere in the US$50-60 range. Plus, you'll have the pleasure of knowing your braking systems (and hence, your safety) are up to snuff. Even better? You can easily do the upgrade yourself with simple hand tools.   
The price of stainless lines is roughly the same (sometimes cheaper) as rubber lines and fittings (on the OEM diagram, you have to buy the banjo bolts and washers separately). Plus, you'll have the pleasure of knowing your braking system (and hence, your safety) is up to snuff. Even better? You can easily do the upgrade yourself with simple hand tools.   


Why not? Be the first on your block!
Why not? Be the first on your block!


====Installation of stainless steel lines, by IanJ====
==Installation of stainless steel lines==
 
This tutorial follows the installation of Galfer stainless steel brake lines from Cycle Brakes.
 
'''Brakes are critical'''
 
A complete novice should not attempt this operation if you're at all uncomfortable about it - not because it's hard, but because you're working with the brakes, which are one of the systems that will get you killed fastest if you mess it up. If you're not comfortable with the idea of doing this yourself, get a friend to help out. Even another novice is useful in having another pair of eyes to double-check your work, but a mechanically experienced friend is best.
 
It's a good idea to only work on one brake system (either front or rear) at a time. That way you know that even if you do something wrong, you'll still have brakes at one end of the bike. If you take everything apart right away, you have no guaranteed backup.
 
====Pre-reading====


On MIK's recent advice to another poster, I purchased a set of Galfer stainless steel brake lines from Cycle Brakes. Total cost was $103 and change, with the front line costing $55, and the rear $40 (although it was a higher cost to order the rear line by itself), and $8. something for shipping. The order was placed on a Friday, and I had the new lines sitting on my doorstep in Seattle in four days, over Memorial Day weekend.
If you've never worked on your brakes before, you should take a look at:


I used the following tools to do the installation:
*[[How do I change the brake fluid?]]
*[[How do I bleed the brake lines?]]
 
====Notes on brake fluid====
 
*Use DOT4 fluid. '''Don't use DOT5'''. Putting DOT5 in a DOT4 system could destroy brake system components, leading to catastrophic failure.
*Containers of brake fluid should be kept closed at all times, unless you're actually pouring it out. This keeps out excess moisture and also keeps the fluid clean.
*Grit or impurities in your braking system are a strict no-no, as they could gum up the fluid passages, leading to possible brake malfunction. So, keep the reservoir covered unless you're actually pouring in fluid or rapidly removing it.
*Brake fluid is also a moderately effective paint stripper, so wipe up any spilled brake fluid as quickly as possible. It can destroy the paint on your bike, but it doesn't work immediately, so there's no reason to panic.
 
====Tools====
   
   
*hand-operated vacuum pump
* #2 Phillips screwdriver  
* #2 Phillips screwdriver  
*10mm wrench  
*10mm wrench  
*12mm wrench  
*12mm wrench  
*14mm wrench  
*14mm wrench  
*14mm socket  
*14mm socket (sizes may vary)
*torque wrench  
*torque wrench  
*small rubber mallet (handy, but not required)  
*small rubber mallet (handy, but not required)  


I used the following supplies:
====Supplies====


*Galfer SS front brake line with banjo bolts  
*Galfer SS front brake line with banjo bolts  
Line 48: Line 110:
*numerous rags  
*numerous rags  


First thing was to take the cover off the front brake fluid reservoir (#2 Phillips screwdriver), being careful not to drip any fluid on the bike (or wipe it up quickly where I did drip). Then I used the vacuum pump, attached to the bleed nipple on the front brake, to suck the old brake fluid out of the system. It was dark brown with lots of nasty swirling black stuff -- I'm pretty sure this was the original brake fluid from the factory (2001 model year bike). The bleed nipple takes a 10mm wrench.
For bleeding the brakes:
*Several feet of 3/16" inside diameter vinyl tubing
*An empty resealable bottle (milk bottle, soft drink bottle, etc.)


With the fluid out of the front line, I disconnected the banjo bolts at the caliper and handlebar (12mm wrench). I kept the bolts and washers to compare to the same items supplied by Galfer. The factory bolts were ~3mm longer than the Galfer bolts, but that doesn't make any practical difference. Galfer supplied copper washers (with two spares, I was pleased to note), and the factory washers were silver-colored (aluminum? not sure). Again, no practical difference, I'm sure.
====Removal of old line====


One of the ends of the front line had a bend in the fitting, and I quickly determined that that was the bottom of the line. I left the old line in place while attaching the new line (the Galfer banjo bolts take a 14mm wrench), to make sure it ran on the same path. It appears that the Galfer line is slightly longer than the factory line, which, in combination with being stiffer, means it's likely to rub a bit -- I'll be keeping an eye on it for the first thousand miles to make sure it's not abrading itself dangerously.
Take the cover off the brake fluid reservoir (#2 Phillips screwdriver), being careful not to drip any fluid on the bike. Sop up the fluid in the master cylinder with a paper towel. Then you need to use one of two methods to get the rest of the fluid out of the line:


Installation is simple, just attach each banjo using a washer on each side, and torque to 12 ft-lbs as recommended by Galfer. I highly recommend getting a proper torque wrench to do this: you really don't want to over- or under-torque brake fittings, since that's an excellent way to destroy your only means of slowing down. 12 ft-lbs feels like very little torque, and the only way to accurately measure it is with a good torque wrench. If you just "screw 'em in until they're tight" you'll almost certainly break the banjo bolts.  
Semi-messy way: Wrap a paper towel around the bottom banjo and remove that, then remove the top banjo.  


At this point, I poured fresh, new DOT4 brake fluid into the reservoir from a sealed bottle that I had from a year or two ago (note: this is probably not ideal, but since it was still sealed, it's not bad). I used the vacuum pump to pull the new fluid into the system via the bleed nipple, and discovered that pulling half the vacuum gauge in is a bad idea -- it sucked all the fluid through the system and still had 90% of its vacuum left. sluurp! I tried again, this time keeping that 10mm wrench handy, and only operating the handle once or twice to pull fluid through the system slowly. That worked much better, and I was able to get most of the bubbles out in a few minutes.  
Slower way: Attach the 3/16" tubing to the bleeder screw on the caliper and let gravity do the work for you, just as though you are [[How do I bleed the brake lines?|bleeding the brakes]]. The bleed nipple takes a 10mm wrench.


The operation that seemed to work best was to fill the reservoir up, pull fluid through with the vacuum pump, then close the bleed nipple as soon as I saw some fluid coming through the tube. Then I could pull the vacuum pump tube off to lose the vacuum, reattach it, and use it as a high-class mason jar. With the reservoir cover on, pump the brake handle several times, then open the bleed nipple and pull a very slight amount of pressure with the vacuum pump. This would pull the air bubbles out, and in combination with some sharp pulls on the brake handle, I got all the bubbles out. Tapping gently on the caliper and fittings with a small rubber mallet also helps.  
Put the old fluid in a sealed container and dispose of it according to local guidelines.  


The rear brake line installation was nearly identical, although I had refined the bleeding procedure enough that it went a lot faster. The rear line may have been easier to bleed as well, since the basically flat orientation of the line, and the raised caliper should mean that bubbles rise to the bleed valve more easily. To access the rear brake fluid reservoir, you'll need your screwdriver to get the right-hand side panel off.
With the fluid out of the front line, disconnect the banjo bolts at the caliper and handlebar (12mm wrench). Keep the bolts and washers to compare to the same items supplied with the new line. If the length of the bolts is slightly different, that won't make any practical difference. Make sure you check the threads, though, and see that the pitch is the same.  
In all, the brake line installation took around 40 minutes to complete both front and rear. Trying to do the job without the vacuum pump might take a little longer or waste a little more brake fluid (note that once you've opened a bottle of brake fluid, you use it right then or toss it, so "wasting" brake fluid is kind of hard to do).  


A complete novice should not attempt this operation if they're at all uncomfortable about it -- not because it's hard, but because you're working with the brakes, which are one of the systems that will get you killed fastest if you mess it up. If you're not comfortable with the idea of doing this yourself, get a friend to help out. Even another novice is useful in having another pair of eyes to double-check your work, but a mechanically experienced friend is best.
====Installation of new line====


If you don't have the more advanced tools I mention here (the torque wrench and the vacuum pump) I would definitely spend money on the torque wrench first. Buy the best one you can afford, as this is a tool that will be useful for years to come if you intend to do any amount of work on your bike. Definitely don't buy a bar-n-pointer type wrench unless that's really all you can afford. If you can scrape together $60, the clicker-type torque wrenches are much more accurate and repeatable. Sears, Home Depot, Lowes, etc. are good places to get torque wrenches. Vacuum pumps (the small, hand-operated variety) are available from automotive stores like Schucks, AutoZone, Pep Boys, NAPA, etc. I think mine cost $25-30, and that seems to be a typical price. So far, I've used my vacuum pump to bleed brakes and hold the vacuum petcock on the Ninja open, so it's not ultimately a widely useful tool like the torque wrench is.
One of the ends of the front line will have a bend in the fitting, which should help determine which end is the bottom. Leave the old line in place while attaching the new line, to make sure it runs on the same path.
 
Notes on brake fluid: DOT3 and DOT4 brake fluid are hydrophilic, which means that they readily absorb moisture, which degrades their ability to work properly. DOT5 fluid must not be used in a DOT4 system -- the two types don't mix, and putting in the wrong type could destroy brake system components, leading to catastrophic failure. Containers of brake fluid should be kept closed at all times, unless you're actually pouring it out. This keeps out excess moisture, and also keeps the fluid clean. Grit or impurities in your braking system are a strict no-no, as they could gum up the fluid passages, leading to possible brake malfunction. Keep the reservoir covered unless you're actually pouring in fluid or rapidly removing it.  
To fill the line: Attach the bottom banjo bolt (see next paragraph), then fill the line from the top with a funnel, being careful about spillage. Attach the top banjo and then fill the master cylinder. Once it's full, [[How do I bleed the brake lines?|bleed the brakes]]. Make sure you get all the air bubbles out of the line. Keep the reservoir cover on to avoid splashing, and make sure to fill the reservoir when the fluid level gets low, to keep air out of the system.
 
Attach each banjo using a washer on each side and torque to the brake line manufacturer's specs (12 ft-lbs is recommended by Galfer). Use a [http://faq.ninja250.org/wiki/A_beginner%27s_guide_to_maintenance_tools#Torque_wrench torque wrench]; you really don't want to over- or under-torque brake fittings, since that's an excellent way to destroy your only means of slowing down. 12 ft-lbs feels like very little torque, and the only way to accurately measure it is with a good torque wrench. If you just "screw 'em in until they're tight" you'll almost certainly break the banjo bolts.
 
The rear brake line installation is nearly identical. To access the rear brake fluid reservoir, you'll need your screwdriver to get the right-hand side panel off.  
 
Check the new line every so often, to make sure it isn't rubbing anything that could make it wear prematurely.
 
====Installation suggestion====
 
If you look at your new lines and it seems that they may rub in places, pull the rubber tube (front) and spring (front & rear) off the old line and put it over the new one. For the tube part, you may want to use something like WD40 to slide it off and on. The spring won't fit over the banjo bolt, so you have to finesse it on. Get it started on the line, then hold the line and twist the spring, as shown with the demonstration pen at right.
 
[[image:846824.jpg|150px]]
[[image:100_0592-2.jpg|150px]]
 
If this doesn't work, just use something else in the places that need it. Look at your new line and decide for yourself if it's rubbing anywhere. If you see potential chafing, you should put something on there to chafe instead of your line. Electrical tape isn't really right for the job. Rubber tubing is better. 3/8" fuel line, sliced lengthwise, has been suggested. A flexible piece of rubber or plastic can be wrapped around the spot that is rubbing and held in place with zip ties. Spiral wrap is a good choice, too.  
 
While you're at it, take a look at the rest of the cables/hoses/wires on your bike. Look for places where something rubs, and either re-route or add chafe padding.


Brake fluid is also a moderately effective paint stripper, so wipe up any spilled brake fluid as quickly as possible. It can destroy the paint on your bike, but it doesn't work immediately, so there's no reason to panic.
==Riding impressions==


Riding impressions: At this point in time, I've only been able to ride the bike about 15 miles, but I could tell a distinct difference from the first pull on the brake lever. Brake activation is much more linear now; with the factory lines, the brakes would be linear up until the 50-60% point, then braking force would remain about the same, even though more pressure was applied to the lever or pedal. My best theory to explain this is that the factory rubber brake lines, being "springy," would just start expanding, rather than transmitting any further force to the brake caliper, at around 60% force.  
You should be able to feel a distinct difference from the rubber lines when you pull on the brake lever. Brake activation is much more linear with stainless lines. With the factory lines, the brakes are usually linear up until the 50-60% point, then braking force remains about the same, even when you apply more pressure to the lever or pedal. The factory rubber brake lines, being "springy", start expanding, rather than transmitting any further force to the brake caliper, at around 60% force.  


This translates into a really nice feel when applying the brakes with the new lines in place. It also feels as if more aggressive pads have been fitted, since they continue increasing pressure beyond ~60% now. I'd say it breaks down like this:  
This translates into a really nice feel when applying the brakes with the new lines in place. It also feels as if more aggressive pads have been fitted, since they continue increasing pressure beyond ~60%. Subjective feel breaks down like this:  


{| border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="5" align="center"
{| border="1" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="5" align="center"
Line 98: Line 178:
|}
|}


As you can see, the steel lines are more responsive, but the difference only really shows up when braking pretty hard. I suspect that, in normal riding, I won't notice the difference very much. Only when stopping rapidly will I notice very much, and then the new lines will really shine.  
As you can see, the steel lines are more responsive, but the difference only really shows up when braking pretty hard. You might not notice the difference very much in normal riding. It's when stopping rapidly that the new lines really shine.  


The practical upshot of all this is that I need to go back and re-train myself in emergency braking on the Ninja. Its behavior will now be different enough that my old responses might lock up one or both wheels. As soon as I get the Ninja back on the road, I'll be practicing quick stops in an empty parking lot.  
You should go back and re-train yourself in emergency braking on the Ninja. Its behavior will now be different enough that your old responses might lock up one or both wheels.  


No matter what, the stainless lines look quite nice (I got the "clear" jacket color). They most likely improve safety, since they allow more braking force to be applied to the calipers. Are they worth $103 plus 40 minutes labor? Absolutely. Your situation may differ ($100 may be far dearer to you than to me), but I believe that they're an excellent upgrade to the littlest Ninja.  
No matter what, the stainless lines look quite nice and improve safety, since they allow more braking force to be applied to the calipers. These lines are an excellent upgrade to the littlest Ninja.  


Here are some pictures of the rear line after installation:  
Here are some pictures of the rear line after installation:  


[[Image:rear SS line 1.jpg|250px]] [[Image:rear SS line 2.jpg|150px]]  
[[Image:rear SS line 1.jpg|150px]] [[Image:rear SS line 2.jpg|80px]]  


[[Image:rear SS line 4.jpg|150px]] [[Image:rear SS line 5.jpg|250px]]
[[Image:rear SS line 4.jpg|80px]] [[Image:rear SS line 5.jpg|150px]]